MAVS NEWS: Luka Wins Community Cares Award! | DLive's Mom Passes Away| Maxi OUT

[DanSchwartzgan]

In total, there's a +1, a 0 (with dreams it later becomes a +1), and a -1. The need was to be +2 and so far, it's +0 when added together.

Seems a bit arbitrary.  But it is your post, so you are allowed to set your requirements and your scale.  Given the minutes crunch (something you talk about a lot) at whatever you want to call the position that isn't a big and isn't a ball handler, another player never seemed like a realistic requirement.  Where were the minutes going to come from with Hardaway returning.  

EVERYONE AGREES there is a need for a backup ball handler.

Here is how I would look at it.  In the playoffs we had four players available to us (plus a fraction of Powell) who had had an EPM in the 80th percentile or above within the last three seasons played.  

Luka 96 97 97 
DFS 87 82 82 
SD 74 88 71 
Brunson 85 67 63
Powell 81 72 84.  

If you average the three years you get 97, 84, 78, 72 and part of a player at 79.

We've since added the following compared to the team that ended the playoff run 

McGee 86 83 89 (Avg 86)
Wood 75 92 96 (Avg 88) 
THJ 65 74 87 (Avg 75).  

Using the averages, here is old vs. new:

          Old          New
Luka    97           97
DFS     84           84
SD      78           78
JB       72           75 (THJ)
DP      79            86 (McGee)
Wood                 88

That is at least one addition (and Wood at 88 is a significant addition).  McGee improves Powell in the desperately needed areas of shot blocking and rebounding without giving up his ability to rim run.  Hardaway doesn't replace Brunson's role, but he does replace his points compared to the playoff team.  

The next addition doesn't have to replace Brunson.  He has to replace the ball handling role Dinwiddie played.  But, all he has to do to further improve our playoff team is be better than Green-ikina.  I think we are one deal for someone like Kemba, Beverley, Bledsoe or Rose from being significantly better even after losing Brunson for nothing.  I personally think this thing can carry all the way to the TDL if need be.  We will find that player. 

Let's keep the main thing the main thing.  The question isn't whether the FO screwed the pooch.  The question is whether we are better than the team that lost to GS in the conference finals.  I think we have more talent than that team.  I think to fully utilize that talent we need another body.  It is only August 4th.  If we are still having this conversation in late February, then I'll join the chorus.